Anne Tibbets is a Donald Maass Literary Agency agent known for a highly selective eye — requesting roughly 5% of queried manuscripts — whose precise current wishlist requires direct verification from their live agency page.
In brief
Anne Tibbets operates at Donald Maass Literary Agency, one of the most respected literary agencies in the industry, known for prioritizing literary quality and commercial potential in tandem.
Their selection rate is strikingly low: in a publicly shared sample month (March 2026), only 10 of 195 queries — roughly 5% — earned a request to read. Writers should treat every element of their submission as load-bearing.
Because their agency page was inaccessible at the time of this profile's compilation, the precise current wishlist, genre priorities, and submission guidelines must be confirmed directly through the agency's live materials before querying.
Query status was observed as open as of April 16, 2026, and a May 2026 social post confirms active query reading — both are encouraging signs, but writers should verify current status before submitting.
The Donald Maass agency has a strong track record with character-driven commercial fiction; authors querying Anne Tibbets should expect a representative who values craft, voice, and emotional resonance above high-concept alone.
Lately
BEWARE IMPOSTERS: I will NEVER solicit writers via email. To query me go here: QueryTracker.net/query/AnneTi...
I have finished reading the queries for March of this year. If anyone is morbidly curious, out of 195 queries received that month (this does not include several referrals I received through clients and colleagues) I requested to read 10.
Dream Report: A Journalist major, an Accounting major, an ROTC Criminal Justice major, & a Computer Science major team up & investigate a cold serial killer case from their university's history & find out the killer is still active. Gen Z amateur detectives! WHO HAS A MANUSCRIPT LIKE THIS I WANT IT
Reading queries like
So many writers querying me with their names uncapitalized. Like, is this a choice - a trend? Or a typo? Someone young explain this to me.
Anne Tibbets shared a transparent look at their query statistics for March 2026: out of 195 queries received that month (excluding referrals from clients and colleagues), they requested to read only 10 — a selection rate of roughly 5%. The tone was matter-of-fact, offered as information for writers curious about the odds.
What Anne is looking for
Anne Tibbets's current genre wishlist could not be fully retrieved due to a technical barrier on their agency page. Based on their affiliation with Donald Maass Literary Agency — an agency with a deep history in commercial and upmarket fiction — and the high selectivity of their reading requests, they are almost certainly seeking work with strong voice, distinctive characters, and emotional or thematic depth. Writers should consult the live agency page to confirm specific categories before querying.
Not the right fit
Taste fingerprint
How to query Anne
With only about 5 requests per 100 queries in a recent sample month, every sentence in your submission must earn its place — treat your query letter as the single most important document you will write for this project.
Referrals from existing clients and colleagues are received separately from the general query pool; if you have a legitimate professional connection to the agency or its clients, a warm introduction may meaningfully improve your visibility.
Because the agency page was temporarily inaccessible, confirm the current submission guidelines, preferred genres, and any required materials (synopsis length, page count, etc.) directly through the agency's live form before submitting.
Donald Maass Literary Agency has a well-established identity around voice-driven, emotionally resonant commercial fiction — frame your pitch around what makes your story's emotional core and protagonist compelling, not just its plot mechanics.
Check the live agency page for any stated genre restrictions or preferences; submitting outside their current wishlist is a common and avoidable reason for rejection at this selectivity level.