Comp title

Literary agents who want books like The Night Circus

13 agents have named The Night Circus as a comparable title on their wishlist, and 5 are open to queries. If you’re pitching something in this lane, these are the agents to know. Always confirm an agent’s submission window before you query.

13 agents5 open to queries
CC
Catherine Cho
Paper Literary
Open to queries

She actively wants speculative premises — magical realism, time travel, dystopian settings, the fantastical woven through the literary. The concept should feel

View wishlist →
GL
Gracie Freeman Lifschutz
Dystel Goderich & Bourret LLC
Open to queries

She's interested in character-driven adult fiction with genuine literary ambition — stories that spark conversation. Non-traditional family structures and deep,

View wishlist →
JE
Jessica Errera
Jane Rotrosen Agency
Open to queries

Errera is actively hungry for speculative fiction with warmth, wit, and humanity — the kind that blends magical or fantastical elements into deeply felt contemp

View wishlist →
QR
Quressa Robinson
Folio Literary Management
Open to queries

The widest-open lane. Robinson wants adult science fiction and fantasy that genre-bends and reaches beyond core SF/F readers — atmospheric, high-concept, commer

View wishlist →
SF
Sam Farkas
Jill Grinberg Literary Management
Open to queries

She wants beautifully written, voice-led stories with strong hooks that feel simultaneously of-the-moment and built to last. Her sweet spots include lyrical, im

View wishlist →
CR
Catherine Ross
Corvisiero Literary Agency
Status unverified

Fantasy with lush, immersive world-building and prose that earns its atmosphere. Strong pull toward supernatural folklore — Caribbean folklore in particular is

View wishlist →
ES
Eric Smith
Neighborhood Literary
Closed

Smith's stated sweet spot: fiction that pulls a bit of genre into the literary register. They want category-crossing, upmarket storytelling and explicitly invit

View wishlist →
EL
Esty Loveing-Downes
Howland Literary
Closed

She is looking for upmarket novels centered on women, especially those with queer representation or that update or reimagine classic narratives. She values emot

View wishlist →
JA
Jennifer Azantian
Azantian Literary Agency
Closed

This is where her passion runs deepest. She wants sweeping, immersive fantasies with a powerful sense of place — the kind that pull a reader in from the opening

View wishlist →
KO
Kristin Ostby
Salky Literary Management
Closed

She's looking for adult fiction that sits at the intersection of literary sensibility and commercial readability—specifically in comedy, mystery, romance, and h

View wishlist →
KH
Kristy Hunter
The Knight Agency
Closed

Romantasy is one of her top adult priorities. She wants propulsive writing, a distinctive hook, and the kind of wide commercial appeal that turns books into con

View wishlist →
TC
Thérèse Coen
Susanna Lea Associates
Status unverified

For adult fiction, Coen gravitates toward literary and upmarket work — prose that earns its ambition, whether through style, structure, or depth of character. H

View wishlist →
VM
Victoria Marini
High Line Literary Collective
Closed

This is the center of gravity on her actual sales list, backed by multiple NYT and indie bestselling series. She wants the full spectrum — sweeping second-world

View wishlist →

Comp titles are drawn from what each agent has publicly said they’re looking for. A comp signals taste, not a guarantee — read the full profile before querying. Browse more comp titles →