Comp title

Literary agents who want books like The Only Good Indians

13 agents have named The Only Good Indians as a comparable title on their wishlist, and 5 are open to queries. If you’re pitching something in this lane, these are the agents to know. Always confirm an agent’s submission window before you query.

13 agents5 open to queries
CL
Chad Luibl
Janklow & Nesbit Associates
Open to queries

Luibl wants horror and thrillers that are as inventive as they are scary—he's drawn to work that uses genre machinery in service of literary ideas. Think atmosp

View wishlist →
KE
Kelsey Evans
Rosecliff Literary
Open to queries

Cult narratives are her single loudest request in horror — she lists them three times with visible enthusiasm. Beyond cults, she gravitates toward horror that f

View wishlist →
LH
Logan Harper
Jane Rotrosen Agency
Open to queries

Harper is specifically hungry for horror that functions as a family saga in disguise — emotional dread layered over supernatural threat. Psychological horror, g

View wishlist →
MB
Maria Brannan
Greyhound Literary
Open to queries

This is Maria's most articulated priority. She wants horror with a genuine perspective: narratives rooted in female rage or women's lived experiences, folk or r

View wishlist →
SF
Sam Farkas
Jill Grinberg Literary Management
Open to queries

Female-centric suspense with genuine twists and compulsive pacing is a clear priority. She also wants fast-paced thrillers with a light speculative edge, and at

View wishlist →
AL
Alex Land
Mad Woman Literary Agency
Closed

This is her most emphatic priority. She gravitates toward horror that carries dark humor and social texture — think ensemble casts in nightmarish scenarios, fem

View wishlist →
DM
Dorian Maffei
Kimberley Cameron & Associates
Closed

She describes herself as actively hunting in this space and uses enthusiastic language — 'spooky and spellbinding,' 'haunting and beautiful,' stories that keep

View wishlist →
EP
Eloy Bleifuss Prados
Neon Literary
Status unverified

He wants gothic and horror novels that earn their dread through emotional grounding — not pure shock value but fear that emerges from character and place. His c

View wishlist →
LH
Lane Heymont
The Tobias Literary Agency
Closed

Horror is Heymont's declared specialty and his deepest personal passion. He is fluent in the full canon — Gothic fiction, cosmic horror, psychological dread — a

View wishlist →
LK
Lexie Krauss
Marsal Lyon Literary Agency
Closed

Horror is clearly a priority. Krauss is open to a wide range of horror modes — literary and feminist horror, cosmic and eco/nature horror, 'bubblegum horror' (f

View wishlist →
SR
Shelly Romero
Azantian Literary Agency
Closed

Horror is Romero's defining passion and her top priority across MG, YA, and adult. She wants nearly all subgenres—gothic horror, paranormal horror, psychologica

View wishlist →
TK
Tamara Kawar
DeFiore and Company
Closed

She wants contemporary, historical, and gothic horror, with particular enthusiasm for gothic set in non-Western contexts, and queer/trans/feminist horror with s

View wishlist →
TO
Tricja Okuniewska
Putnam
Status unverified

This is a narrow but genuine appetite: Okuniewska wants horror that lives at the crossroads of dread and thriller momentum, ideally with rich nature writing, a

View wishlist →

Comp titles are drawn from what each agent has publicly said they’re looking for. A comp signals taste, not a guarantee — read the full profile before querying. Browse more comp titles →